Skip to main content

The Ethical Dilemma of Accepting Tainted Donations

Cause marketers and others have made much of the recent cause marketing campaign by KFC benefiting Susan G. Komen for the Cure.

My old pal Joe Waters at the Boston Medical Center and his many commenters have stated very well the ethical dilemma that charities can face in forging cause marketing relationships.

But, of course, the charititable fundraising business as a whole is fraught with ethical challenges.

Here’s a particularly challenging and recent one from the UK that has come to my attention.

Reginald Forester-Smith was a ‘photographer to the stars’ and royalty in the United Kingdom the 1970s.

In 1999 he was tried, convicted and jailed for repeatedly raping his young daughter over an 18-year-period. He spent eight years in prison. At least two other girls came forward to say that Forester-Smith had sexually abused them as well. His daughter, now aged 42, published a book about her experience in 2002.

Forester-Smith served his time and died last July at the age of 77. His wife, Sheena, died in 2001. Forester-Smith’s estate bequeathed more than £1m to three charities, including £312,291 each to the Macmillan Nurses Cancer Association and Cancer Research UK.

Now news has come out that Forester-Smith had also bequeathed £400,000 to Girlguiding Scotland, an analogue in the United States to the Girls Scouts.

So if you’re Girlguiding Scotland, do you take the money?

Here’s a few things to keep in mind.
  • Forester-Smith served his time.
  • Forester-Smith is dead.
  • Forester-Smith left nothing for his daughter.
  • Neither the Macmillan Nurses Cancer Association and Cancer Research UK have announced yet whether they will accept the gift, so Girlguiding doesn’t have any cover from them.
  • The estate made the gift to the Girlguiding Scotland in memory of his wife, who was an active supporter of the Girl Guides and Brownies.
  • Girlguiding Scotland is particularly well-placed to use the money to fight child abuse in all its odious forms.
All that said, you can appreciate why Girlguiding is taking its time thinking about this bequest.
  • Isn't accepting it tantamount to a whitewash of Forester-Smith's horrible crimes?
  • Forester-Smith's money is all but blood money.
  • His daughter has so far remained silent, but a family friend has said that it would be reprehensible for Girlguides to accept it.
I’d love to get your opinion. Should Girlguiding Scotland accept the donation or not?


Stephany said…
They should accept it and immediately give every penny to the daughter.
Dawn W said…
What if the punishment for his crime were being stripped of his wealth and the court designating the money to charity?

It's the same money, but emotionally I suspect that we'd feel better if the money came to the charity titled "punishment" instead of "gift." I know I would.

There is so much need in the world. I hope that the charities take the money - and create some good, some assistance, some hope for those in need.
Wouldn't it be cool if they brought the daughter in, perhaps to administer a program training girls in how to spot/avoid/report abuse? I think especially since Forester-Smith is dead and can't benefit from the publicity (and may have named the beneficiary as an act of remorse), it wouldn't be blood money--but should be earmarked specifically to be used in ways that undo the damage he and his ilk have done.
Stephany makes a point that many commenting in the newspapers in England have made; the daughter deserves some recompense.

Dawn's point, I think, is very penetrating. Andrew Carnegie was a ruthless competitor and sometimes a not very nice man. His wealth came from environmentally rapacious enterprises. Much the same could be said about John D. Rockefeller. But few are the charities that would decline grants from either the Carnegie or Rockefeller foundations, both of which have given away tens of billions over the last 100 or so years.

Shel sorta splits the baby, allowing the daughter to administer the funds. I have no idea what kind of administrative experience she has, so I can imagine that the charity would be chary of this idea. But why not bring her in as an adviser? She literally wrote the book on parental child abuse. Who better to help girls recognize the danger signs?

Thanks to all of you for your comments!

Warm regards,

Popular posts from this blog

Top Eight Cause-Related Marketing Campaigns of 2007

Yeah, You Read it Right. It's a Top 8 List.

More cause-related marketing campaigns are unveiled every day across the world than I review in a year at the cause-related marketing blog. And, frankly, I don’t see very many campaigns from outside North America. So I won’t pretend that my annual list of the top cause-related marketing campaigns is exhaustive.

But, like any other self-respecting blogger, I won’t let my superficial purview stop me from drawing my own tortured conclusions!

So… cue the drumroll (and the dismissive snickers)… without further ado, here is my list of the eight best cause-related marketing campaigns of 2007.

My list of the worst cause-related marketing campaigns of 2007 follows on Thursday.

Chilis and St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital
I was delighted by the scope of Chilis’ campaign for St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital. As you walked in you saw the servers adorned in black co-branded shirts. Other elements included message points on the Chilis beverage coas…

The Alden Keene Cause Marketing Stock Index Dramatically Outperforms Other Indices

There are stock indexes galore; the Dow, S&P 500, the NASDAQ Composite, the Wilshire 5000, the FTSE, and hundreds more. But how would an index of the stocks of companies that do a meaningful amount of cause marketing perform compared to those well-known indexes? Pretty well, as it turns out.

I first floated the idea of a stock index that would track companies that do cause marketing back in 2009. I tried to figure out Yahoo Pipes so that I could put the feed right into this blog. But alas sometimes the geek gene does fall pretty far from the tree.

So I talked to programmers to see if I could find someone who could do the same, but it was always more than I was willing to pay.

Finally, last week I hired a MBA student to do it all in a spreadsheet, and what do you know but that over the last 15 years a basket of 25 cause marketing stocks dramatically outperforms the Dow, the S&P 500, the NASDAQ Composite, and the Wilshire 5000.

The index, which I call the Alden Keene Cause Market…

Cell Phone Fundraising

There you are walking down Lake Shore Drive past the rising Chicago Spire building eating a Chicago Red Hot, when you’re struck by a billboard with a message from, say, MercyCorps, asking for help providing relief to the cyclone-battered people in Myanmar’s Irrawaddy delta. But the sign doesn’t feature a website URL, a toll-free telephone number or even an address to send a check. Instead the sign tells you to text the word ‘Give’ to a number using your cell phone and a $5 donation will be made.

To the Japanese or Europeans that scenario probably sounds not so much futuristic as so 2006.

But it’s new in the United States, made possible by lower fees from the cell phone carriers. If analysts are correct, cell phone fundraising may be a prominent future fundraising channel for charities with a clear mission, strong brand recognition and the ability to effectively get their message to their audience.

What’s the potential upside of this mobile phone fundraising in the United States?

“$100 mil…