Years ago Junior Achievement had one of the most cleared-eyed policy manuals on cause marketing I’ve ever come across. It was insightful, strictly ethical, thorough, and filled with good ideas. And you’re going to have to take my word on all that because I can’t find it in my files or on the Junior Achievement website. If anybody has a copy, I’d love to see it again.But I wonder what that Junior Achievement policy manual would have said about this modest campaign from an AlphaGraphics store in Salt Lake City?
In celebration of the store’s founding and the owner’s birthday, they’re hosting a BBQ benefiting Junior Achievement next Wednesday. Proceeds from the sale of the meal benefit the nonprofit charity whose three-part mission is youth development, education development, and economic development.
The programs and materials at Junior Achievement (JA) are strong. It calls on more than 375,000 volunteers worldwide who serve tens of millions of kids. It has a clean operating record, a long history, a broad reach, and an important mission.The result is that JA is like catnip for sponsors. HP, Fedex, Sam’s Club, General Electric, Barclays Bank, Citi, Capital One, and others all give $500,000 or more a year. AT&T gives more than $5 million. And the postcard sized handcard at the left demonstrates that Junior Achievement is attractive to small companies, too.
If JA has a challenge it may be that there’s not much emotion traveling along with all its common sense appeal. That may be why they filled their 2010 annual report with so many images of Junior Achievers from desperately poor conditions.
So far as it goes there’s nothing wrong with this local campaign except a poverty of ambition. JA is an estimable cause and a terrific fit for AlphaGraphics. It deserves more.
- Why not close the street block the store is on and hold some kind of 'beat the pro' contest with players from the Utah Jazz (the NBA team) or the Real Salt Lake (Major League Soccer team) for a small donation? And invite their cheerleaders too.
- What about a long putt competition for $10 a putt? That would be fun/different on pavement. Structured correctly, an insurance policy would allow you to offer a $10,000 top prize for couple hundred dollars.
- Where’s the auction element? Where's the raffle?
- Will the mayor be there? What about the Chamber of Commerce?
- Why not invite local TV?
- What about a radio remote?
- Have the newspapers been alerted?
- The Facebook element is nice, but where’s the rest of social media outreach? This oughta be the site of meetups for several Twitter groups for the week.
- Where’s the appearance by the hotshot JA alumni who’s gone on to create XYZTech?
- Why not let all local JA volunteers eat free so long as they bring along a pal that pays for himself or herself?
What else could AlphaGraphics do inexpensively to generate funds and awareness? Weigh in with your ideas in the comments section below.
Comments
Paul Jones here. To answer your questions, no I did not contact the owner of the AlphaGraphics store. This blog is primarily a source of opinions about cause marketing. There's plenty of places to go if you want news about cause marketing. Email me and I'll steer you towards several.
Any assumptions I made were based on the store's promotional material, which I included in the Post. I passed no judgement on what this store, or AlphaGraphics as a whole does for Junior Achievement or any other charity.
My post was based entirely on what they could do to make this promotion better, not on what they have or haven't done in the past or what they intend to do in the future.
I think if you reread my post you'll find that while it is strongly worded, it's not terribly critical of this store or of AlphaGraphics in general.
Finally, you make an excellent point about small businesses getting hit up for many donations. Part of being a small business owner is decided what to say no and what to say yes to.
Do you hire new people or not? Do you buy new machinery or not? Do you promote your product or service in the newspaper or not? Do you donate to a specific charity or not?
Many businesses large and small, handle the charity donation question by broadly spreading their donation budget around.
Another approach is to pick a handful of charities and tell everyone else that their priority is that small handful of charities.
There's a hot debate among corporate donors about which approach is the best.
In the event that a small business chooses to support only a handful of charities, one of the things the business probably ought to do is really throw its energy behind its support of those causes.
The payoff of this post, if I can be so bold, is ideas about how to do so for this one small promotion.
Thanks for your comments. I appreciate your passion.
Warm regards,
Paul